Easter Contest

23 03 2008

Just wanted to say happy Easter to everyone. Also had a little contest to throw up there on this special day. I’ll be giving away my game used spring training hat from this year. Signed and inscribed (picture below). First person to guess my favorite Easter treat wins. ONE guess per person. Hope everyone has a great day with friends and family. Good luck!

img_0302.jpg 


Actions

Information

736 responses

23 03 2008
rand0mhero89

Butterfinger easter bunnys?

23 03 2008
mike34

How about those cream filled eggs?

Happy Easter!

23 03 2008
hihosilver13

Chocolate Bunnies

23 03 2008
austinmatherne

Peeps?

23 03 2008
dannyf113

Peeps marshmallow bunnies?

Happy Easter

23 03 2008
tonybeat

I’m going to have to go with jelly beans.

23 03 2008
giambinyy25fan

chocolate easter eggs

23 03 2008
mike72988

Reeses’ Peanut Butter Eggs?

23 03 2008
jaewon

Boston Creme donut.

23 03 2008
sdibartolo1

marshmellow peeps

23 03 2008
anthony

Cadbury’s!

23 03 2008
anaconda44

Jelly Beans

23 03 2008
yankees2456

cadbury caramel eggs

23 03 2008
berniepaulntino

chocolate easter bunny

23 03 2008
23 03 2008
helyeah996

cadbury mini egss

23 03 2008
allenri2

sour patch kids.

23 03 2008
bobbykid

I will keep it simple and guess a hershey bar

23 03 2008
nyanks5124

Jelly Beans….I have no idea…just trying to pick something no one else has said.

23 03 2008
agkanter

Chocolate easter cookies?

23 03 2008
docpain

Easter Cupcakes!

Yay, i won !! whooohooooo

23 03 2008
rcf3

since no one else has said it yet, im going with chocolate covered marshmellow eggs

23 03 2008
fakehanksteinbrenner

cadbury cream eggs

23 03 2008
sdm1130

How about caramel filled bunnies?

23 03 2008
uncwyanksfan

cadbury creme eggs

23 03 2008
jjj2121

I forget what their called, but those candy coated speckled eggs that are crispy on the inside???

23 03 2008
thekiltedwonder

Dark chocolate bunnies.

23 03 2008
thehugeunit

Peeps

23 03 2008
bleachers39

PIZZA RUSTICA BREAD….NO ONE SED IT YET

23 03 2008
littlekittynyc

Happy Easter, Phil~
I usually don’t participate in the contests…but this one I think I will try…..

My guess is chocolate peanut butter eggs.

Can’t WAIT for Opening Day!!
GO YANKEES!!!

~Rebecca

23 03 2008
frostnyc

gonna have to go with Reeses’ Peanut Butter Eggs…

23 03 2008
defensewins

Cake, shaped and made out to look like Easter symbols, such as bunnies, etc.?

23 03 2008
manimal529

Happy easter phil, Greek easter is in 2 weeks so Ill wait for my easter.

Anyways my favorite is those malted milk egg thingys so Ill guess that.

23 03 2008
manimal529

by the way that is an awesome signature.

23 03 2008
hughesphranchise65

white chocolate

23 03 2008
yankeemansam

PEEPS!!!

23 03 2008
ashleynicole1987

Heyy Phil,

Happy Easter!!

I’m guessing that your fav easter treat is the Reese’s Peanut Butter Egg. (thats mine, lol)

23 03 2008
bronxbomba

Im gunna have to say Dove Chocolate eggs

23 03 2008
ishmael430

gonna be real specific: starburst jelly beans…

23 03 2008
jetersgurl4eva

Cadbury’s mini eggs

23 03 2008
2yankees143

I’m gonna go with Cadbury eggs and Happy Easter to Everyone!

23 03 2008
wiyankee

A colored hard boiled egg.

23 03 2008
kuoda

3 musketeers

23 03 2008
studio8h

cadbury cream eggs

23 03 2008
oopy493

Snickers eggs?

23 03 2008
trvlc

Nestle Crunch eggs?

23 03 2008
timdogg

malted chocolate eggs

23 03 2008
dexileno

Chocolate Pretzels

23 03 2008
wastedtalent

Bah wanted to say Peeps but it was already guessed….hmmm

Going to be specific:

Cadbury Caramel Eggs

23 03 2008
bv189

Marshmallow peeps. Happy Easter

23 03 2008
seffapotamus

M&M’s ?

23 03 2008
donnybball23

Can’t remember who makes them, but…

Chocolate Nest with jelly beans in the center.

23 03 2008
jmunnelly3

Cookies-n-cream bunny? Happy Easter Phil!

23 03 2008
dswinograd

Cadbury Cream Eggs…i love em!!

23 03 2008
Tim Daloisio

Tiny Beany Jelly Beans

23 03 2008
mgb5

Reester Bunny? Anyway Happy Easter.

23 03 2008
chinnisny

I’m guessing Reeses Kit Kat Bars. That’s mine!
Thanx

23 03 2008
evilmonkey35

peanut butter chocolate bunny

23 03 2008
~ Patricia

Licorice flavored jelly beans?

23 03 2008
gtownresident

jelly belly jelly beans

23 03 2008
dynastynyy

MINI cadbury cream eggs :)

Damn, I was watching the game and missed seeing this

23 03 2008
pinstripesintheblood

Im going to go with good old fashion Ham

23 03 2008
alexbyanks

Cadbury’s dark chocolate mini eggs

23 03 2008
zellyanks91

Hot Cross Buns

23 03 2008
jessicayanks

chocolate easter eggs!

23 03 2008
psychopoo

Chocolate Truffles?

Have no clue I was gonna say jellybeans or peeps but they were taken

23 03 2008
philfan

jelly beans.

23 03 2008
grgoyldef2

Red Jelly Beans

23 03 2008
timmyloops

3 Musketeers bar

23 03 2008
pdriggs2029

A Carvel Ice Cream Cake in the shape of a Rabbit/Bunny head!

Ok so maybe that’s my favorite….

23 03 2008
edodge

jolly rancher jelly beans

23 03 2008
dannysong

Yellow peeps

23 03 2008
settes

Clay Buchholz’s still-beating heart

23 03 2008
adamc23

Mallow Cups!

23 03 2008
daveeiland

Peeps, yellow to be exact

23 03 2008
morineko

Chocolate orange?
(and have a good Easter yourself!)

23 03 2008
joblogchamberlain

sweet tarts. They’re my favorite.

23 03 2008
yankfan508

hollow chocolate bunny!

23 03 2008
erin2549

Gertrude Hawk Chocolate

23 03 2008
jz5178

Big Chocolate Bunny

23 03 2008
bx26

Jelly bellies

23 03 2008
probe31

Rice Krispie Treats ?!!!!!

-pete

23 03 2008
yankee4liferu1

ham with pineapple

23 03 2008
evilempire13

happy easter man, im gonna say starburst jelly beans.

23 03 2008
tjyankee21

Skittles Easter Filled Eggs

23 03 2008
bleedpinstripes

starburst jelly beans

23 03 2008
alupo790

jelly beans come on phil everyone loves jelly beans

23 03 2008
neildo84

Cadbury’s Creme Eggs!

23 03 2008
fan4life

I’m gonna go with eggnog.

I know its more of a christmas treat but everything else was already said.

23 03 2008
arodmariano4213

Hershey Kissesur the man Hughes

23 03 2008
jburd

Hard Boiled Eggs?

LOL…have a great Easter Phil!

23 03 2008
yankeefaninidaho

frosted sugar cookies, and a nice shot of wild turkey to wash it down.

23 03 2008
bigthree346231

twix

23 03 2008
ccorcoran

cadbury eggs

23 03 2008
gruli15

Sugar Eggs???

23 03 2008
skba91

Jelly beans

23 03 2008
kissanem

cadburry eggs

23 03 2008
yankees65

I am going to go with those candies that are shapped like easter eggs but taste like a Whoppers. Those things are so good, I’m not really sure what they are called though, hope fully its your favorite.

23 03 2008
spoondoggy

I’m gonna say since you’re an athlete, hardboiled eggs, for your protein!

23 03 2008
hnice

here’s my guess:

phil’s favorite easter treat is not taking 18 hour flights to and from japan a few days before the start of the regular season.

do i win?

23 03 2008
sfp99

The hollow Easter Choc. egg with a toy surprise inside!

23 03 2008
conyermr

M & M’s

23 03 2008
yankeegirl65

well my favorite is snickers in the shape of an easter egg with baseballs on them haha so ill guess that even though its probably not right

happy easter!

23 03 2008
tsengsational

One of those oreo-white chocolate hershey bars?

23 03 2008
got17

Kinder Surprise

23 03 2008
briancromer

Whoppers!

23 03 2008
sportsrock333

Cadbury chocolate eggs

23 03 2008
clem21

Hersheys creme filled kisses

23 03 2008
noah7393

marang cookies?

23 03 2008
estechler

Yellow Peeps

23 03 2008
3sr8jr

Peeps. I wish it wasn’t first come-first serve for the contests, but thanks for the blog Phil!

23 03 2008
kimmyankees

Reeses Peanut Butter eggs

23 03 2008
scottishgigolo

I’ve gotta guess my personal favorite. Despite not actually being a specific easter candy…

Skittles?

Also Phil good luck this year, we’re all rooting for you.

23 03 2008
gonyanks21

Ferrero Rocher’s!

23 03 2008
ras1121

bacon!!!

23 03 2008
mattnyytoronto

ill guess creme eggs but its already been said.

23 03 2008
benjadoff7

im gonna go with jelly beans

i love the starburst ones

23 03 2008
pinstripedgirl

Simnel Cake…. happy easter

my favorite are blue peeps and cadbury’s

23 03 2008
allen62

A White Chocolate easter bunny

23 03 2008
santoast

Jordan Almonds.

23 03 2008
lvlike

White Chocolate

23 03 2008
kendee1

Cadbury Egg

23 03 2008
demarco5

peanut butter eggs

23 03 2008
arod13rulez

pez

23 03 2008
Travis G.

Krackel

23 03 2008
dig4fire

caramelized french toast

23 03 2008
jillybean426

The sweettart animals

23 03 2008
snapples

butterfinger eggs

23 03 2008
amour217

Cadbury Caramel Eggs

23 03 2008
moemdown42

delicious easter hen

23 03 2008
pqn0788

cadbury egg?

23 03 2008
mat33

Chocolate mint?

23 03 2008
tracyls1

Sweet potatoes with marshmallows.

Happy Easter, Phil and everyone.

23 03 2008
pkbowler

m&m’s

23 03 2008
jerkblog

Lamb chops with lamb gravy, mmmm I’m eating it right now.

23 03 2008
cromartiehopsparty

starburst jelly beans

23 03 2008
johnnymac11

chocolate covered pretzel….my favorite anyway

23 03 2008
nyyanks23

Favorite Easter treat hmmmm……….. Let’s see…..

Easter Dinner with the family

23 03 2008
pmacker

DEVILED EGGS!!

23 03 2008
26yanksrule27

Too bad I’m Jewish, but I’ll say chocolate bunnies.

23 03 2008
cgarct

if not straight vodka playa, it’s gota be Pretzels.

23 03 2008
powder62

since everyone is taking candy i am going with

Easter Ham

23 03 2008
killaj27

PEEPS !

23 03 2008
sportslifer

Black jelly beans. Enjoy your blog.

The Sportslifer at http://sportslifer.wordpress.com/

23 03 2008
ciggaman

anything godiva

23 03 2008
xsandman42x

Coconut Egg

23 03 2008
staceyx3nyy

A Hershey’s Dark Chocolate Bunny :)

23 03 2008
holladollas

If it’s not a BJ, you’re a liar.

23 03 2008
mdmiller

Almond Joy Coconut eggs

23 03 2008
cbullom0779

cadberry eggs

23 03 2008
scottsocial

snickers

23 03 2008
newyorkvol

Moms homemade chocolate bunnies

23 03 2008
ny426

Marshmellow Eggs?

23 03 2008
missyla

chocolate cupcakes

… my posts arent showing up

23 03 2008
joeuva10

PEEPS!

23 03 2008
hball4su

Cadbury Eggs!

23 03 2008
condobil2

Chocolate covered Strawberries………………………….
Happy Easter to you

23 03 2008
norcross77

cadbury caramel egg

23 03 2008
goyanks24

cadbury eggs

23 03 2008
jaredx16x

poppy seed/net roll

23 03 2008
jerseyboyoak

skittles

23 03 2008
pastorella143

fudge easter egg

23 03 2008
pgo237

Jelly Beans

23 03 2008
pgo237

A world series ring

23 03 2008
bigjf

Since pretty much everything else was guessed, I’m going with vanilla cream filled hershey kisses. I’m pounding down some of those right now. delicious!

23 03 2008
emilyd08

twizzlers

23 03 2008
bigjf

By the way, I’m watching the YES interview with the 3 amigos right now. funny stuff!

23 03 2008
ilovenyy

someone already said the snickers egg (my fav.) so how about…

-the little pieces of gum that come in the little egg carton-

Hope you had a great Easter Phil, and thanks for the contest!

23 03 2008
justinslowik

I’ll say Cadbury Eggs

Happy Easter Phil

23 03 2008
dobface8

cadbury eggs

23 03 2008
mrsvickid

reester bunnies

23 03 2008
jwongnyy

White Chocolate Easter Bunnies

23 03 2008
yankeefan34

Dove Truffel Eggs

23 03 2008
arkeytec

rice krispie treat chocolates

23 03 2008
ferrandon

strawberrys with sugar and cream lol

23 03 2008
markus34nyy

White Chocolate Bunnies

23 03 2008
seannryann

Cadbury Creme Egg

23 03 2008
dfox

pizza

23 03 2008
ishotthejukebox

Peeps

23 03 2008
Matt Gaul

Gummy Worms

23 03 2008
millenniumphalcon

Reeses

23 03 2008
flafunguy3

I’m late….was watching the Yankee Game
But I’ll say…home made apple pie

23 03 2008
nymetsgrrl94

Bunny shaped peeps

23 03 2008
japrui

Pez ?

23 03 2008
bigdogg48

Perugina Baci Chocolate Easter Egg with secret prize…usually a plastic bracelet…lol..

23 03 2008
thekillabeejc

Happy Easter! It is probably Reese’s Peanut Butter Eggs, but it has been said a few times. So I will go specific with Smuckers Jelly Beans.

23 03 2008
allstarkitty2112

Happy Easter!! reeses peanut butter eggs

23 03 2008
nyfaninla

Crab?

23 03 2008
yankeelover

black jelly beans

23 03 2008
johnmvp

happy easter everyone from http://www.johnmvp.com ! have a great one with the family

23 03 2008
melkysbabii28

I think its a hollow chocolate easter bunny :) Thats mine! lol

Happy EASTER PHILLY! tell the other guys the same for me

~*Chrissy*~

*ps philly is your nickname from me and my friend jessi…we call you philly cheesesteak*

23 03 2008
sethmurphy

Reese’s Peanut Butter Eggs

23 03 2008
yeagermeister

SInce I just pounded some homemade Lasagna, Im going to have say Lasagna. Its an Easter treat to me at least.

23 03 2008
nyyfan12

reese’s peanut butter egg.

23 03 2008
sirvlciv

Since all of my guesses have been made already….

Pickled eggs?

23 03 2008
xslider138

Sweet tarts

23 03 2008
drdc93

white chocolate bunnny

23 03 2008
27rings27

scalloped potatoes

23 03 2008
27rings27

turkey

23 03 2008
rayblay

no clue seeing as how i don’t even celebrate easter but i’m sure one of you must be right…

Just wanted to say that interview on YES for the Yankees season preview show was freakin’ AWESOME – the MOST amazing interview, SO much fun!!!

23 03 2008
yankeestadium08

I’m going to go with nerds

thanks for the contests phil. you are the man!

23 03 2008
27rings27

cheesecake

23 03 2008
maverickdmb

Pecan Pie! Happy Easter!

23 03 2008
27rings27

chocolate cream pie

23 03 2008
rikers

Lots & Lots of Peeps. Happy Easter Phil

23 03 2008
huizdu

obviously it is a hug from your mom

23 03 2008
kaitlyn482

st josephs lol

23 03 2008
rebeccaoptimist

Manichewitz Jelly Slices.

(What? They always hit the shelves round now, anyway…)

23 03 2008
funsy49

Cake. Chocolate cake.

23 03 2008
scorpio01

mini-chocolate rice crispies eggs? roast leg of lamb??

happy easter!

23 03 2008
barroidbonds

Taking a family photo? Might be more of a hassle then a treat.

23 03 2008
yankbaseballfan

Easter cupcakes.

Happy Easter Phil.

23 03 2008
yanks34

Dove dark chocolate easter bunny

23 03 2008
bighurt35

Obviously it’s JELLO CHEESECAKE!
Thanks for putting on the contest Phil.
Your awesome!

23 03 2008
bamayanksfan

Chocolate cheese cake? (all the good easter candies have been mentioned)

23 03 2008
27rings27

A big wave to Ride

23 03 2008
hughesfan94

jolly rancher easter lollipops

23 03 2008
jessedwards

Cadbury Cream Eggs would have been my guess, but since that’s been said several times….I guess I’ll have to think here…

The Easter themed peanut M&Ms?

Happy Easter everyone! :)

23 03 2008
watersportgurl11

Oh man i think i am between two. Either jelly bellies with all the crazy flavors ( come on who doesn’t like trying all the flavors those people come up with) or jello jigglers shaped like eggs. But i think I am gonna go with the jello eggs cause i don’t think anybody said that yet.
Happy Easter to you and your family!! <3 Sarah

23 03 2008
jd102000

A Hollow easter bunny ears first

23 03 2008
firemedic

chocolate malted eggs

23 03 2008
andrew1979

Chocolate pudding pie

Happy Easter all

23 03 2008
kristoph28

lamb?

23 03 2008
ssclemsonyankees3387

A big Easter Ham?

23 03 2008
Brad Williams

I’m going to go with Marshmallow Peeps.

23 03 2008
thecaptain15

I would have went with Peeps, but I am incredibly late. LOL

So I will say Honey Baked Ham.

Happy Easter everyone!

http://www.madein1903.com/forum

23 03 2008
yanksace34

PEEPS????? GOOD LUCK THIS SEASON

23 03 2008
61studio

Easter Bread/Buns?

I think just about everything else has been covered.

23 03 2008
dfresh2708

Babyruth bar

23 03 2008
doraemon25

Chocolate Covered Marsh Mellow Eggs

23 03 2008
munson152

peeps

23 03 2008
yankeefanjj

chocolate bunny

23 03 2008
mrjeter2

Raspberry Sherbert

23 03 2008
smc402

rabbit

23 03 2008
yankeelor

hard boiled eggs

23 03 2008
sca12

kit-kats

23 03 2008
27in2008

almond joy eggs?

23 03 2008
jboogie

Fluffer Bunnies

23 03 2008
kmdizzle

My fave treat are pastel colored M&Ms. I’ll guess they’re yours also.

23 03 2008
nyycaptain2

haha i’ll say jelly beans although its prob way to late to win this contest

23 03 2008
hughes65

hot-cross buns

23 03 2008
kent72

Angel’s food cake…?

23 03 2008
mrg5890

Lamb Shank?

23 03 2008
howemi01

Hot cross buns..?

23 03 2008
ksolly

anything with white chocolate?

23 03 2008
dumbo20

Coconut cake.

23 03 2008
nyknicks

twizzlers

23 03 2008
King Tom

Jalapeno Jelly Beans?

23 03 2008
mdgforce

I can’t think of the exact name, but those candy eggs that are solid color on the outside (but there are different colors like blue, pink, green, white, etc…orange are the best) and white in the middle. The outside “shell” is almost pure sugar and the inside is more of a “fluffy” sugar. Sometimes they are individually wrapped in clear plastic, but sometimes you can just buy a bag full of them. I love those things! I don’t know if they’re just called candy eggs or sugar eggs or something like that, but they’re great! That’s my guess…

23 03 2008
derekpeter

Chocolate eggs filled with carmel

23 03 2008
crazygiftkid

caramel apples

23 03 2008
mattyh7

Hershey kiss with almonds. Thats mine anyways. =)

23 03 2008
hawkeyes12990

chocolate eggs?

23 03 2008
mdgforce

Ah, just found the official name…they’re “Brach’s Bunny Basket Eggs”

23 03 2008
dilbert195

york peppermint patties

23 03 2008
dougparrish

reese’s pieces eggs

23 03 2008
mudville9

Candy seems to be taken – Asparagus?

23 03 2008
blackjaws19

cake in the shape of an easter egg

23 03 2008
andrewstebbins

Stale peeps.

23 03 2008
bro03

those orange chocolate carrots

23 03 2008
mattysaps

Hard Boiled Eggs!

23 03 2008
ihc560

Hot Dogs

23 03 2008
section37

cadbury mini eggs, the sugar coated shell ones

23 03 2008
puff09

Tofu. Yummy!!!

23 03 2008
stephmac

carbury eggs

23 03 2008
stephmac

cardbury eggs i meant

23 03 2008
merk13

I guess I’ll go with the milky way.

23 03 2008
gmerger37

im going with peeps

23 03 2008
yanksbaseball

easter pie

23 03 2008
yankeejohn

Cadberry eggs!

Happy Easter to all!

23 03 2008
nyisles

The Ten Commandments on TV :)

23 03 2008
shannon6fan

pumpkin pie?

23 03 2008
cdeete01

happy easter, phil!

robin’s eggs! (those whopper things!)

23 03 2008
mezzd98nyy

peeps. gotta be the peeps

23 03 2008
tumblingdice03

I’ll say Nestle Butterfinger Nest Eggs!

23 03 2008
philofthefuture

Happy Easter Phil!

Lemon Meringue is Phil’s favorite

23 03 2008
robbie42003

reeses pieces

23 03 2008
cheeker25

the reeses eggs

23 03 2008
yankscheer

PEZ!

Happy Easter :)

23 03 2008
nfarone

Peeps

23 03 2008
rastaseed0731

Gum

23 03 2008
dewallace

mounds

23 03 2008
uptowngirl710

Easter bread?

Happy Easter everyone!

23 03 2008
shoegirl18

Pie!!

23 03 2008
bronxbomers228

coconut nest with jelly beans

23 03 2008
patroy

mr munchy chocolate bunny

23 03 2008
maxbuds

roast lamb

23 03 2008
meganashley1978

Peeps

23 03 2008
sau1980

Reeses’ Peanut Butter Eggs

23 03 2008
showbiz0618

A day of from work or hard boiled colored eggs.

23 03 2008
philhughes217

Hey Phil,
I think it’s chocolate easter eggs

23 03 2008
unccmeangreen12

PEEPS!

23 03 2008
yanks2007

How about Milk Duds? They’re my favorite!

23 03 2008
sircomstockload

Peeps !!

23 03 2008
militaryyank

It has to be PEEPS

23 03 2008
ayashin716

those mini egg shaped gum balls

23 03 2008
yankeesx26ws

yams? lol

23 03 2008
mysonisnamedmariano

jelly beans

23 03 2008
yankees2451

Malt Balls

23 03 2008
bwozar

licorice jelly beans?

23 03 2008
boodah35

Im going with:
Apple pie w/ Ice Cream

23 03 2008
nsugz

Chocolate bunny.

23 03 2008
bleachercreatures

I’m sure someone guessed it already, with most of the obvious choices taken.

Simnel cake

23 03 2008
njyanksfan

you don’t eat candy? Had to take a shot…. :)

23 03 2008
mrclutch

Easter M&M’s

23 03 2008
pete59

crispy chocolate bunnies!

23 03 2008
chan141

Popping Mini Eggs

23 03 2008
joelefko

chocolate covered gummie bears?

23 03 2008
monzo

Peeps?

23 03 2008
stephj24

Spending time with your adorable nieces and your family

Thanks for the contest!

23 03 2008
bucknut7

Its gotta be black jelly beans

23 03 2008
jannapolen

Apple pie- trying to change it up

23 03 2008
chaossolver

those chocolate egg stuff…
everybody has said everything possibly associated with easter candy…

23 03 2008
dhead0213

peanut butter filled easter bunnies

23 03 2008
ejg415

hollow chocolate bunnies.

23 03 2008
newyorkgirl

cadbury mini eggs – the milk chocolate kind?

p.s. can’t wait for the season to start!

23 03 2008
yankeefan2008

Im gonna say that your favorite easter treat is a PEANUT BUTTER MELTAWAY.

HAPPY EASTER AND GOOD LUCK THIS YEAR

23 03 2008
Rob Moretti

i have to say peeps

23 03 2008
yankeefan3462132

well even though it has been said i am going to say hard boiled eggs
but they are “dyed hard boiled eggs”
that is my guess
go yankees

23 03 2008
39poolshark

Happy Easter Phil!

Im going to guess, LAMB. It’s my favorite Easter meal.

23 03 2008
yanks2win162

peeps

23 03 2008
shivardo

I’m gonna say deviled eggs

23 03 2008
ksyankee

Russel Stover cocnut+chocolate nest

23 03 2008
brook07

Phil,

I hope you had a Happy Easter!!! My guess is Jelly Belly Jelly Beans…

Take care
Good Luck in ’08

23 03 2008
eldane

Cadbury eggs

23 03 2008
sportsman1616

starbursts?

23 03 2008
legendsnpinstripes

jelly belly jelly beans

23 03 2008
Ron Davis

orange cadbury creme eggs

23 03 2008
philrules34

A win?

Thanks. Good luck tomorrow.

23 03 2008
ksyankee

Russle Stover coconut+chocolate nest.

23 03 2008
lovenyankees

Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups???

23 03 2008
bernbabybern

OK, every candy and dinner/dessert item seems to have been guessed ….

so …

A pancake breakfast!!!

23 03 2008
sccrdave05

struffalas.

23 03 2008
gehrig444

yellow peeps

23 03 2008
jerryd1949

Phil:
You’ve gotta love those PEEPS!!

23 03 2008
hughesmark

Gotta go with a personal favorite.

Polish Kielbasa with horseradish.

Good Luck this year.

23 03 2008
yankeeknut09

cadburry eggs

23 03 2008
floridamale

Happy Easter everyone…………
My Grandparents are from Poland….So my mother made this bread…..stuff every Easter it was a big think in my family……. it was an Easter ritual…..& it was great…..& I haven’t had it in a long time…..But it was great…..don’t know how to spell it but I will do my best……With a name like Hughes I guess I wouldn’t win
But I’ll try……………………………Paoska

23 03 2008
emobassfoo

twix

23 03 2008
stevenwiltz

Cadburry eggs

23 03 2008
hughesrocks

I am going to go w/ Peeps also just because its my favorite.

23 03 2008
zib9

i wanna say peeps.. but you say the first person who guesses wins and there’s like 40 guesses of ‘peeps’ already..
soo let’s go with those chocolate covered marshmallows in the shape of eggs.
those are good..

Happy Easter Phil!!

23 03 2008
woozie

I don’t think anyone has said Carrot Cake.

Thanks Phill!

23 03 2008
hughesfan34

phil,
it would probably have to be peeps. Happy easter phil

23 03 2008
nyy4life

jelly beans

23 03 2008
phildaman

Reese’s eggs

23 03 2008
shenbaseball10

jelly beans

23 03 2008
mitchmaster440

My top 5 guesses are gone so i will guess… Jolly Ranchers

23 03 2008
atomicdawg08

how about Reese’s Peanut Butter Eggs?

23 03 2008
phughesismyidol

Reese’s Peanut Butter Bunnies?

23 03 2008
Bleed Pinstripes 13

Robin’s Eggs

23 03 2008
willlaux

marshmellow peeps.

23 03 2008
drsuperstitous

popcorn balls

23 03 2008
yanksgal07

Wow…I was with my family and just got home. I have no clue and I don’t know if it was mentioned but I’ll go with Hot Apple Pie & Ice Cream. Seems every candy ever made was mentioned already …lol.

Happy Easter to Phil & all the bloggers ..

Go Yankees 2008 !!!!

23 03 2008
buckfoston26

ham

23 03 2008
barkley16

fuzzy peaches?

23 03 2008
jyates129

Reese’s Peanut Butter Eggs

23 03 2008
minihughes65

M & M’s

23 03 2008
samanthaasdf

a yankee win. thats all I could ask for on easter, and every other day.

23 03 2008
catlikethief82

gotta be cadbury’s eggs!

23 03 2008
milehighyanks

Easter bread

23 03 2008
bigtic01

those little hard shell chocolate eggs

23 03 2008
yanksrule191

fish

23 03 2008
dimagg5

I’m going to say Red Jelly Beans.

23 03 2008
mcman4687

Turkey?

23 03 2008
mmarkz26

teddy grams!

23 03 2008
discode

malt balls

23 03 2008
philtystuff

Raisin Bread… anything with raisins?

23 03 2008
pats1fan

Jelly Belly Jelly Beans

23 03 2008
mnntwns24

whoppers

23 03 2008
mikeytherhino

Easter Nachos!

Why not, don’t think anyone else has gone there yet….or would want to :-) Happy Easter and Let’s Go Yankees!

The Rhino

23 03 2008
jgallant99

Starburst Sour Jellybeans

Thanks for the contest Phil

23 03 2008
bvos11

I’ve got it bro…

Little Debbie’s seasonal Easter Cakes

23 03 2008
nyyfan3462

chocolate bunny

23 03 2008
petethebrit

I would have to say Devilled Eggs and Ham now send me the hat Bud !!!!!

23 03 2008
ryanstartedthefire

reeses peanut butter eggs

23 03 2008
kevthegreat

Gotta be the red jelly beans.

23 03 2008
kingfossilman

coconut flavored jelly beans

23 03 2008
salvatore22

those sweet tarts bunnies and ducks are good..happy easter !

23 03 2008
mediccook

Easter M&M’s.

23 03 2008
shilleh84

the bunny or egg shaped marshmellows that are stuffed in chocolate…lol..i love those

23 03 2008
sfg2829

hot tamales

23 03 2008
bobber21

butterfingers

23 03 2008
nyyanks71377

BABYRUTH!! HAPPY EASTER PHIL!!

23 03 2008
nyyfan5

Lasagna

23 03 2008
yankees5580

Reese’s peanut butter eggs

23 03 2008
yankeesdjt2

Cadbury creme eggs.

23 03 2008
9nine9

I have no idea, so I’ll take a shot with Peeps.

23 03 2008
vermilion23

Reese Egg Thing

23 03 2008
dahouse292

jelly filled eggs

23 03 2008
mantlemurcer

Jelly Beans

23 03 2008
macback11

those little crunch eggs

23 03 2008
y4nk335

White chocolate easter bunny

23 03 2008
bethnyyfan

The pineapples on top of the Easter ham. :)

23 03 2008
niven311

popcorn balls

23 03 2008
ihateumps17

Mashed Potatoes?

23 03 2008
cja128

French Toast with syrup and butter

23 03 2008
trigg182

pastel chocolate eggs….the chocolate eggs that the pastel melts in your mouth and the chocolate is delicious….

23 03 2008
yankees2134

peeps

23 03 2008
teddyrock

Easter Mini Kit Kat Bars

23 03 2008
kimballstanley2

cadbury eggs

23 03 2008
goblue2112

strawberry and creme hershey kisses

23 03 2008
benware29

scalloped potatoes

23 03 2008
miggs62

kielbasa

23 03 2008
phughesrocks

peanut butter and chocolate covered marshmallows with sprinkles……and some hot cocoa ????

just needed to guess something original

23 03 2008
alex4yanks

it has to be Reeses peanut butter cups shaped as an egg… i love those:)

23 03 2008
alex4yanks

oh and phil, when are you pitching next i havent been able to see u!!!

23 03 2008
bambambpt

Jelly Beans I guess.

23 03 2008
jumpingjon

marshmallow chicks

23 03 2008
jgrannie

dove chocolate eggs

23 03 2008
chrislago07

hersey bars crackel variety

23 03 2008
brianna24

white chocolate bunny

23 03 2008
schaefer486

cadberry eggs

23 03 2008
yankeefangene

where my “peeps” at big phil peeps

23 03 2008
eh270

Chocolate covered ants

23 03 2008
lokomo62

Malted milk Balls ‘eggs’ … absolutely delicious!!

there tiny and i loved em’ ever since i was a kid!

23 03 2008
riverwolf2005

Gotta be Peeps

23 03 2008
mack16v

Yo what up phil ?! How about chocolate covered cherries!

23 03 2008
yankeechic26

I’m going with the speckled egg gum that comes in the egg carton thing

23 03 2008
royceda59

Gotta be those peeps. Oh yeah hopefully you whoop the Phillies’ asses tomorrow.

23 03 2008
tallicafan87

peeps

23 03 2008
yankeesteve

Caramel Filled Chocolate Easter Bunnies

23 03 2008
hewes25

Peeps

Happy easter to you too.

23 03 2008
yankeefan89

fruit flavored tootsie rolls

23 03 2008
johnwalsh11

Russel Stover Chocolate Easter Bunny?

23 03 2008
swg0827

Phil:

You like the sweet tarts that they make for easter.

Good Luck
Steve

23 03 2008
yankspinstripes2

Butterfinger Crème Eggs….. yummmm…….

23 03 2008
x3ssp92x3

peeps!
Happy Easter to you too!

23 03 2008
hughes34

reese peanut butter eggs.

23 03 2008
bronxbomber65

Swiss Chocolate; in bar or bunny form.

23 03 2008
james5348

sold white chocolate easter bunny

23 03 2008
gisia13

hershey’s lemon creme kisses!

23 03 2008
nyywinningdoesnttake86yrs

your fav treat is seeing the easter bunny at the mall? huh? huh?
ok i know i know….i lost but everything was taken already lol

well anyways HAPPY EASTER!

23 03 2008
usako34

Pizza Rustica

23 03 2008
seanecurran

The hard boiled easter eggs? It’s a real shot in the dark!

23 03 2008
ctlvyanks11

I will go with Pez….they are fun to play with.

23 03 2008
jkudo

Everything is already taken, I think I’ll just say Happy Easter Mr. Hughes.

23 03 2008
orangewally

BOILED EGGS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
HAPPY EASTER PHIL

23 03 2008
washkow

It must be Hershey’s Take 5 candy bar. It is so delicious it stretches legality.
andy
newyorkrunning.blogspot.com

23 03 2008
njtrouble

M & M’s

23 03 2008
stoph00

Lets see, what hasn’t been said? How about chocolate raisins?

23 03 2008
pburke22

cream eggs

23 03 2008
misslovely301

vanilla ice cream!

23 03 2008
panzacs50

Peanut M&M’s

23 03 2008
cheffish

Jelly beans

Happy Easter!!!

Katie

23 03 2008
bbbaseball2

cadbury mini eggs!

23 03 2008
midwestredsoxfan

dude if your like me your feeling the rolo’s

23 03 2008
yankeechick78

Cadbury Chocolate Creme Eggs

23 03 2008
broadwaybelm

THIN MINTS

23 03 2008
jtroia13

Red Jelly Beans

23 03 2008
10evert

The egg hunt is always a big treat

23 03 2008
trueplaya202

I actually dont think this has been guessed

Smarties?

23 03 2008
mattgeiger05

How about Oh Henry Chocolate Eggs. It ain’t easter without some of those.

P.S mow ‘em down tomorow bud

23 03 2008
jb222

favorite easter treat is seeing your family

23 03 2008
beemer239

i don’t know if they still sell this stuff ? Could it be marzipan (almond paste) lambs that they sell in bakeries?
Thanks for signing your autograph for my son in Tampa. It really means a lot to him. Have a great season!

23 03 2008
JobaRules

Caramelized Onions?

I hope you had a nice Easter Phil!

23 03 2008
h8boston

Reese’s Peanut Butter Eggs

23 03 2008
jmerr62

an easter egg hunt. happy easter

23 03 2008
tmacdaman1

Happy Easter, Phil

I’ll go with Brown Sugar Pound Cake

23 03 2008
entersandman42

There is no way that someone hasn’t guessed correctly yet but I guess I’ll take a stab and pray.

chocolate covered marshmallow eggs

23 03 2008
kenny32

Blueberry Pie

23 03 2008
Danny

Reese’s Peanut Butter Eggs

23 03 2008
picklerust

Circus Peanuts.

23 03 2008
bcrespi

Postacio cake

23 03 2008
yanks6562

I’m guessing Peeps. And I also guess you like to microwave them…

23 03 2008
yurule315

I’m just going to go out on a limb, and say Big League Chew. hahaha Happy Easter Folks, good luck this season Phil!

23 03 2008
serjicalstrike0

Swedish fish

23 03 2008
abbyroadme

jelly beans

23 03 2008
gisia13

come on, phil, give us a hint if no one’s guessed it yet. this one’s hard!

23 03 2008
eshelmanjamesb

nut roll

23 03 2008
yankstl

I’m going to say Nerds jelly beans – they are so addictive! I think they’re new this year though so they may not be your favorite…

23 03 2008
ywjames

I really have no idea…but I am going to throw up a funny one just for fun.

A BASEBALL MADE OF CHOCOLATE!!! LOL

23 03 2008
eshelmanjamesb

Speckled Malted Eggs

23 03 2008
slayercommathe

Ham??? lol

23 03 2008
ld1173

wow, i’m really late with this..
but i’ll guess vanilla creme cadbury eggs. i don’t like ‘em much but i have a friend from college that loves them!

in any case, hope you had a blessed Easter. The Lord is risen! He is risen indeed. praying for you and the guys always! =)

23 03 2008
deniro20

Happy easter ! gunna go with bunnyettes

23 03 2008
eshelmanjamesb

Anyone else now hungry?? LOL

23 03 2008
love2cheer30

Gertrude hawk chocolate smidgens?
Hope you had a happy easter!

23 03 2008
yankiesboi

without a doubt its gotta be the Snicker Easter Eggs!!!

hope you and your family have a happy and healthy easter!

23 03 2008
rdf8585

Italian ice

23 03 2008
cjv521

it’s gotta be peeps!

23 03 2008
bkny27

reese’s peanut butter eggs?

23 03 2008
midloviking

those yellow marshmellow ducks

23 03 2008
bolts939

pizza

23 03 2008
mlobay

cadbury eggs

23 03 2008
srizzle88

peeps

23 03 2008
skxstealth

Uhh those.. its like gum in the shape of easter eggs.. they come in like a plastic carton… they’re like a dozen mini easter egg gum balls… original no?

23 03 2008
gibby

Starburst sour jelly beans.

I didn’t read the 500 posts to see if anyone already guessed that.

23 03 2008
clymer33

Jellybeans

23 03 2008
yanksbeatbosox

PEEEEEEEEPPS!

23 03 2008
cupajoba

russel stovers marshmellow eggs

23 03 2008
drewnasty98

reeses penut butter eggs

23 03 2008
ricciocw

happy easter phil…hope you enjoyed it

im gonna guess something besides candy since everyone else has named almost every kind… my favorites lamb so im gonna go with that

23 03 2008
sbloom8

I think it just might be the solid milk chocolate bunny?

23 03 2008
dougsfc97

Peeps?

24 03 2008
mirofoto

In N Out – Double Double – Animal Style

Happy Easter Phil!

24 03 2008
Spencer Schoeben

chocolate… yumm… happy easter phil!

24 03 2008
dar3almackoy

peeps!

24 03 2008
ppearson281

Toblerone

24 03 2008
yankeeace2

cadbury easter eggs

24 03 2008
kyledunne

cadbury eggs.

24 03 2008
johnmvp

Happy Easter from the gang at http://www.johnmvp.com – hard to say but forget about baseball today and enjoy the family. Everybody have a great day!

24 03 2008
12to6

Hershey’s Krackle

24 03 2008
majambo

Cadbury Caramel Eggs

24 03 2008
kellymcmahon

I think you like the special Easter awesomeness that is Sweet Tarts Jelly Beans!!

24 03 2008
kellymcmahon

P.S. Other posters have mentioned Sweet Tarts, but none have guessed that it is their JELLY BEANS that you love!

24 03 2008
24 03 2008
ggalasso

Since must stuff has been said: Cheesy Potatoes

24 03 2008
macdalton

Mini eggs. You know the ones that look like birds eggs and have a crispy outside and a chocolate inside.

24 03 2008
kristy1978

Is it CASATA (Easter Ricotta Pie)? Hope so… ;)

24 03 2008
legendsfield

LITTLE SOLID MILK CHOCOLATE EGGS WRAPPED IN TIN FOIL THAT COME IN DIFFERENT COLORS

24 03 2008
pvanzino

Cadbury Cream Eggs?

24 03 2008
opeth442

Chocolate covered pretzels…I know they’re my favorite.

24 03 2008
bearly

jello eggs

24 03 2008
mabbryfl30

Peanut butter eggs

24 03 2008
westward13

If the contest is to be the first to guess the right answer… and someone’s already guessed a certain answer… why do people insist on submitting the answer again? Peeps? Cadbury eggs? There had to be at least 20 people to guess each one. I don’t get it.

24 03 2008
ericas367

Jellybeans!!!

24 03 2008
vipermj9

sweet tarts

24 03 2008
nyy27thin08

happy Easter Phil!!! I will guess Peanutbetter egg

24 03 2008
misskaleena

Peeps! Rabbit Shaped.

24 03 2008
yanksfan212

how about chocolate covered egg with caramel inside? YUMMY!!:) Happy Easter!!

24 03 2008
hoboken1

ham

24 03 2008
dannyboot

Jelly Beans

24 03 2008
captain15

Peeps…one of the BEST of ALL time…Happy Easter

24 03 2008
tlisowski

Deviled eggs?
All the best to you and your family, Phil.

24 03 2008
seasontix

cadbury eggs

24 03 2008
rickthehick

Rice Krispie treats?

Rick

24 03 2008
myspacecom15keys

Im going to say……………. PEEPS

24 03 2008
upstateyanksfan

Hope you had a Happy Easter w/ your favorite treat.
How about Eggs Benedict?

24 03 2008
jbrady85

lamb chops?

24 03 2008
larrydavid1

cherry-filled chocolates?

24 03 2008
yankeepilot1285

Recees penut butter chocolate egg shaped candies

24 03 2008
mulliganharry

I am going with Peeps. good luck this year.

24 03 2008
ryanleeh

Reeses Peanut Butter Egg

24 03 2008
yankees1982

robin eggs

24 03 2008
yellowhammer

Cadbury Creme Egg

24 03 2008
chrisfitzh2o

Cadbury Caramel Egg

24 03 2008
tino24

Starburst jelly beans.

24 03 2008
vtyankeesfan

Maple Cheesecake

24 03 2008
milehighyankfan

robin’s eggs

24 03 2008
yankeeclipper3974

Hey phil not sure if this one has been tried?

How about a reeses pieces!

Have a great season ill be watching via the baseball package!

Tough being a yankees fan here in Beantown!

But this is our year!

Good Luck & Go Yankees!!!!

D-

24 03 2008
jnr98

(strictly for my) peeps!

24 03 2008
iheartny22

I’ll guess vanilla cupcakes. Hope you are doing well Phil! Take care and have a great day :)

24 03 2008
hennymatt

Cadbury Creme Egg….back in the day when I was 10 I could eat 10 of these in one sitting…yuck!

24 03 2008
jeek322

Pink peeps! Duh…..

24 03 2008
joekliq

Peanut M & M’s. Easter colors.

24 03 2008
cbon9

Peanut Brittle?

Hope you all had a very Happy Easter, and were able to spend some quality time with friends and family.

** Carrie **

24 03 2008
billthebody

chocolate shaped like a cross

24 03 2008
painttheblack23

BLACK jelly beans.

24 03 2008
billthebody

milk chocolate shaped like a cross

24 03 2008
kbee

Pineapple Upside Down Cake?

I had to ask because my sister-in-law made that yesterday.

Hope you had a great Easter!

24 03 2008
mbm165

Reese Peanut Butter Eggs (at least that would be my favorite and I am hoping it is yours as well)

24 03 2008
diamondgirl7

chocolate covered peeps

24 03 2008
rmoore2764

circus peanuts

24 03 2008
pinstripes3926

Gota say cadbury eggs…

24 03 2008
ricrocks

marshmellow bunny thingy! lol

24 03 2008
voodoomagic5

stuffing your face over easter dinner with the family

24 03 2008
meeechiganny

Peeps!

24 03 2008
dledmo

peeps!

24 03 2008
starksfor3

Fraggle stick car

24 03 2008
yankeeghost

Cadbury Mini-Eggs! Those are my favorite.

24 03 2008
yanksinva

Happy Easter Phil.

Are Peeps your favorite??

24 03 2008
drillmon

Marshmallow peeps?

24 03 2008
26ringsandcounting

Gotta go with Peeps.

24 03 2008
yanks216

I’m sure someone already said it, but im not reading through all this to find out:

Cadbury Creme Eggs! They’re the best

24 03 2008
maelias33

colored hard-boiled eggs

24 03 2008
cajunpepe

Hello Phil, well it seems everyone has just about covered every possible Easter treat. But I’ll go a different way, I’ll say that instead of a food item, your favorite Easter treat is time with your family.

Looking forward to the new season> I am excited about our team and teh move toward youth.

Good luck Phil.

24 03 2008
yanks4ever13

So, all of the things that I’d usually guess have already been guessed, so I’m going to go with a treat that’s not edible, because you never explicitly, that that’s the type of treat it was.

So I’m going to say spending time with family and friends on Easter.

Hope you had a good Easter Phil.

24 03 2008
justafan42

I guess I need to check this blog every hour!!

Easter Colored M&M’s?

24 03 2008
pad42

Chocolate covered marshmallow bunnies.

24 03 2008
kodiak141

gobstopper easter egg jawbreakers?

24 03 2008
rmazun

steak

24 03 2008
rickity21

Twizzlers….

24 03 2008
cookidge

Nerds

24 03 2008
psix86

malted milk balls

24 03 2008
jobadance

Pez

24 03 2008
dhaptn

reeces peanut butter egg

24 03 2008
loveyankeebaseball65

Happy Easter!! hope you had a good one. ummm favorite treat……it has to be Peeps.=]

24 03 2008
deftones655

The Reesester Bunny

24 03 2008
nyyankees5582

Lindens dark chocolate bunny , happy belated easter

24 03 2008
yankstallyn

one of those big italian chocolate eggs with the prize inside

24 03 2008
rastaseed0731

Chocolate covered gummi bears

24 03 2008
34phil

phil if i had to guess it would be peeps

24 03 2008
gmoon7

Come on Phil…you love Peeps, right?

24 03 2008
asrexplorer

Phil I am a big fan so you like chocolate bunnies

24 03 2008
saucyflossy

candy

24 03 2008
poopboy59

you like vanilla balls

24 03 2008
wizzardem

Jelly Belly Jelly Beans

24 03 2008
jcyanks08

Reese’s Peanut Butter Eggs

24 03 2008
bronxbomber05

Russell Stover strawberry cream egg
Happy Easter

24 03 2008
carpy22

Cadbury Egg

24 03 2008
jetersgangster

Your favorite Easter treat is Easter mass.

http://respectjetersgangster.blogspot.com

24 03 2008
yankeechick77

Cadbury Eggs?? Can’t wait till next week!!! :)

24 03 2008
justrun7

I’m gonna say blue peeps

24 03 2008
vincemig

snickers eggs

24 03 2008
nyyfan366265

Homemade Rolls.

I saw this way to late, shoot. This is basically the only thing I can think of that hasn’t been said. Praying this is the one. Dominate tonight, 34. Go Yankees!

24 03 2008
calvin418

Since you grew up SoCal, I’m going to say a box of Sees Candy.

24 03 2008
eugiethegreat

How about the Russell Stover Coconut Nest?

Sadly, there are none this year because the geniouses at Stover discontinued them BUT due to overwhelming phone calls they are bringing them back next year. At least this is what I was told.

24 03 2008
csiesta13

I’m going to go with italian grain pie

24 03 2008
hicsolo

Chocolate filled with marshmellow

24 03 2008
bignybugs

Cadbury Mini Eggs

24 03 2008
dasubman1138

Reese’s peanut butter eggs.

24 03 2008
mperrelli953

its gotta be the peeps

24 03 2008
stephaniewilson

gotta go with my favorite –mini cadbury eggs!!

Hope you had a nice holiday Phil…. best of luck
We have faith in you always!

24 03 2008
theshow08

Im going to go with……um how about m&ms

24 03 2008
skydawg303

Junior Mints

24 03 2008
franknyc88

reeses peanut butter cups

24 03 2008
ajm23

hard boiled eggs

24 03 2008
allabouttheyanks

Could it be Easter Bread!!

24 03 2008
jblackmets111

your moms ham

24 03 2008
yanksdmavs2541

Cadburry egg.

24 03 2008
frankiedue

cadbury creme egg!

24 03 2008
jtjt0034

I am going to guess…Cadbury mini Eggs.

24 03 2008
yankeepride13

candy covered chocolate chips

24 03 2008
yankeejetfan

Raisinettes.

Hope you had a good Easter Phil.

24 03 2008
turn2jete
24 03 2008
tarainmadrid

Easter Egg Salad? (After the egg hunt you make egg salad out of the eggs and it’s multi-colored).

24 03 2008
babybombertrilogy

cadbury mini eggs
best candy ever

24 03 2008
littlepatti

Your favorite must be a Laura Secord Easter Egg.
or
Pecan Rolls (anytime of the day, year, month)

PS: And you can send the hat to the runner up. :-)

24 03 2008
bennysbmrs

reese’s peanut butter cups

24 03 2008
granolapeacemama

happy easter

24 03 2008
paddyo6

how about reese pieces, happy easter

24 03 2008
cyalatermd

Pecking eggs? I dont know, Im message 622 gotta try somthing…..

Happy Easter Phil.

24 03 2008
vinviper

I am going with Peeps!!

24 03 2008
lconte17

How about M&M Peanut Butter Speckled eggs

they are the best imo

24 03 2008
hughesowns96

I bet you don’t have a favorite and are just testing us but still it is cool that you give this stuff away.

24 03 2008
dhendler

peeps

24 03 2008
acha2312

deviled eggs.

24 03 2008
jnatro

rice krispie treats

24 03 2008
joba62

I’m guessing Peeps!!!

24 03 2008
bisquerick

I’m guessing that the knowledge that Jesus rose from the dead and ascended into heaven is a treat enough for you, right Phil?

24 03 2008
bboz100

white chocolate bunny

24 03 2008
mannygr

All Easter treats begin and end with Peeps!

24 03 2008
dondonl

As a parent of a toddler, and after 600+ people ahead of me have already guessed almost everything, I’m going to say:

Green Eggs and Ham

24 03 2008
pullinfertheyankers

i just wanna point out that it’s Cadbury Creme Eggs. :)
but my geuss is Nerd covered jelly-beans. just had em for the first time yesterday, theyre awesome.

24 03 2008
docturn2

Hope you had a great holiday! My guess are Robins Eggs….
Good luck for the new season!

24 03 2008
pullinfertheyankers

Sorry about that last comment, it was confusing.
My guess is Nerd-covered jelly beans, and the name of the cream filled eggs are Cadbury Creme Eggs. ;)

24 03 2008
34master1029

Grandmas home made cookies

24 03 2008
jacendezine

jelly beans.

24 03 2008
chasewalk1

I bet it’s a cadbury egg.

24 03 2008
csshads

stale peeps (cuz that’s my favorite!!)

24 03 2008
rjh95

Reese’s Eggs or Marshmallow eggs

Phil can u visit my wordpress

http://rjh95.wordpress.com

24 03 2008
csshads

I’m going with stale peeps -

24 03 2008
davistad44

Reese’s Peanut Butter Eggs

24 03 2008
schmalze4

If you have any taste at all, it would be the old mint dreams. Unfortunately, they stopped making them, but they’re the best thing ever.

Keep that arm loose!

24 03 2008
ultimateyankeefan

whoppers

24 03 2008
kearanne

I”m going to say the ham itself!

24 03 2008
Canada Day

HAPPY EASTER MONDAY PHIL!!! UP HERE IN CANADA, WE CELEBRATE EASTER ON SUNDAY AND MONDAY!!! YOU’LL LEARN THAT WHEN YOU BECOME A BLUE JAY!!…ANYWAYS, I BET YOUR FAVORITE EASTER TREAT IS SOME GOOD OL’ CANADIEN MAPLE SYRUP!

24 03 2008
mikedbm3

don’t think anyone guessed this one…five nut brownie with ice cream

24 03 2008
flyfishermannj

Snickers mini candy bars.

24 03 2008
ansky26

The easter egg gum that comes in the mini carton?

24 03 2008
primetm34

creame filled easter chocolate eggs

24 03 2008
yankeelover143

I would have to say PEEPS!

24 03 2008
gtone

Reeses’ Peanut Butter Eggs

24 03 2008
hughes2joba

umm I would say…starburst jelly beans…see you at opening day!..good luck this year

24 03 2008
allsta2003

watching your nieces hunt for easter eggs

24 03 2008
pb4ugo17

That lindt chocolate peanut butter candy…
or anything with peanut butter?

24 03 2008
thndvdsaid

kit kats

24 03 2008
philipjason25

My Guess would a cadburry caramel creme egg…..mmmm tasty

Although i do prefer the Reester bunny….have you seen this thing giant peanut butter filled easter bunny…awesome!

24 03 2008
dmeyers3

Jelly beans

24 03 2008
yankees2446

Mmmm Sour Patch Kids?

24 03 2008
alemro13

Reese’s Peanut Butter Eggs? They’re the best…

24 03 2008
lavatrna

In Germany we eat “Hefezopf”
I think it is – yeast braid – in English.
I have no idea why you should like that but it hasn’t been mentioned yet.

24 03 2008
yankeesfan024

peeps

24 03 2008
yanks2524

crunch bars

24 03 2008
sleepyleon

mom’s cupcakes

24 03 2008
thebronxstop

Anything from Fleming’s Steakhouse obviously!!!

24 03 2008
mboz100

Rabbit – nothing better to eat on Easter

24 03 2008
jcarr89

lindt chocolate bunnies

24 03 2008
96yanks

I am going to go our on a limb. Probably wrong but….Marsh mellow peeps

24 03 2008
lubedlandlord

EGGS WITH THE CREME IN THE MIDDLE!?

24 03 2008
dagmen17

deviled eggs

24 03 2008
yankeesrule2413

your treat is that you play for the yankees (among 29 other teams). . . actually that’s talent so nevermind

24 03 2008
yanks1219

caramel filled nestle crunch eggs

24 03 2008
vilmafan15

steak

24 03 2008
samaract

I know other people have guessed this already, but it’s not a real Easter without a Cadbury creme egg (I had two yesterday), so I have to go with that. Happy Easter!

24 03 2008
midnightpal1

peeps, or the chocolate bunnies with the marshmellows

24 03 2008
yankeephanatic

a box of chocolates

24 03 2008
eclclieg

girl scout cookies!!!

24 03 2008
andreatc

White Chocolate Easter Bunny

24 03 2008
baseballa120

You dont have a favorite easter treat

24 03 2008
nyyfan4life

carrots….

24 03 2008
wahbjo01

I’ll go with my favorite, the popcorn easter bunnies they seem to have stopped making in the last 2-3 years.

24 03 2008
buzzy05401

Is it Russell Stover Rasberry filled Dark chocolate? That is my favorite Easter treat.

24 03 2008
awt4190

skittles. everything else is taken

24 03 2008
yankee42

a win.

24 03 2008
wnyyankeefan

My favorite is honey baked ham. That’s my guess.

24 03 2008
Pablo Zevallos

an easter egg hunt for chocolate, cream-filled eggs!

24 03 2008
dunkaroos

Phil’s too health-conscious to eat treats. :-)

24 03 2008
nyyanks1

Cadbury creme eggs

24 03 2008
boshon

Reese’s Peanut Butter Egg

24 03 2008
geck002

Cadbury Cream Eggs

24 03 2008
torv

easter bread

24 03 2008
arirang11209

ok phil my guess is hard boiled eggs

24 03 2008
jen1974

reese’s peanut butter eggs?

24 03 2008
jakstra

Kielbasi and horseradish? The home-made kind!!!

24 03 2008
duddly1918

Blue Peeps

24 03 2008
rjh95

i think dots

24 03 2008
mcam09

How about part of my dinner last night, ambrosia?

24 03 2008
thejasper

the yolk of the hard boiled eggs!

24 03 2008
heelatious

Reese’s peanut butter eggs.

24 03 2008
alexalex17

Chocolate Bunnies. A classic that will never go out of style.

24 03 2008
rjh95

thx for commenting on my meebo i already have a pic of it framed in my room :)

24 03 2008
hughesfan3465

Jelly beans, they’re the best

24 03 2008
34and62

going with PEEPS

24 03 2008
spaltor

reese’s peanut butter eggs?

24 03 2008
moose35fannyy

Milky Way chocolate carmel egg

24 03 2008
thescooter

purple jelly beans; nobody’s said it.

24 03 2008
alisrap

Is it peeps???

24 03 2008
littlekittynyc

sweet pitching today, Phil….you had command of your fastball….(who cares about the homer) you K’d 6…nice job! Too bad you didn’t get to pitch 7 innings…

24 03 2008
elishasummers

How about Hot cross buns? By the way, I’m listening to the game tonight on WCBS 880 AM with John & Suzyn. Great pitching performance tonight Phil! Keep it up!

24 03 2008
yankeefanml

creme eggs

24 03 2008
deanr34

Nestle Crunch chocolate eggs

24 03 2008
fixxxer169

peeps

24 03 2008
handsomejoe

It’s got to be non pariels if you have any class!

24 03 2008
xspike21

I’m Thinking PEZ Phil….Thats it right?

24 03 2008
makisupa

Hmm… Favorite treat? Beating the Red Sox?

10 10 2013
Thaline Larocca

u said everything, u rock

24 03 2008
jdwing55

Snicker’s bar

24 03 2008
pinstriped lady

The little Hershey’s crunch bars wrapped in shiny Easter colors? Or just regular Hershey’s crunch bars.

24 03 2008
rangers10

White Chocolate easter bunny

24 03 2008
1960yankees

hello phil i would have to say cherry pie that works for me — have a great year
go yanks
thanks
rich

24 03 2008
spiderzip

Cadbury Creme Eggs!

24 03 2008
hasankarim

jordan almond easter eggs

24 03 2008
fightonusc

Great job on the mound tonight!

Honey ham?

24 03 2008
tbaker1121

Everything good seems to be taken…I’ll go with a nice religious communion wafer.

24 03 2008
mjk2612

peeps!!!!!!!

24 03 2008
hideki4prez

gonna go with your family’s homemade chocolote easter bunny mold…maybe passed on from the grandparents, etc

24 03 2008
cmoney3

im gonna go with (Zitner’s) Butter Krak Eggs no1 has guessed that yet

24 03 2008
bronxbomber65

Solid start tonight phil, 5 innings, and 6 strike outs, congrats.

24 03 2008
blscrdtat

Andes Cream De mints

25 03 2008
hughes2joba

eh not a big eggs fan would of never guessed…good outing the other night…hopefully I’ll see you out in NY I’ll buy you a few beers…goodluck this year

26 03 2008
hawkhawk

I’m going with M&M’S

2 04 2008
asrexplorer

why did you not pick meeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

1 05 2008
mhughes65

Chocolate Marshmallow Eggs.

5 05 2008
yankeeuniverse27

going out on a limb .. . .
egg salad?

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s




Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 188 other followers

%d bloggers like this: